Skip to content
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
CALL STORE
Search
  • Engagement Rings
  • Wedding Bands
  • Jewelry
  • Our Store
  • Services
Search Cart
Left
  • Engagement Rings Toggle menu
    • Custom Engagement Rings
    • In-Store Engagement Rings
    • Lab Diamond Engagement Rings
    • Sally K Engagement Rings
  • Wedding Bands Toggle menu
    • Ladies Wedding Bands
    • Men's Wedding Bands
  • Jewelry Toggle menu
    • Spring Collection
    • Diamond Stud Earrings
    • Diamonds
    • Bracelets
    • Earrings
    • Gift Ideas
    • Necklaces
    • Rings
    • Stackable Rings
  • Our Store Toggle menu
    • About Us
    • Book In-Store Appointment
    • Book Virtual Consultation
    • Contact Us
    • Blog
    • Giving Back
    • History
    • How to Ask
    • Incentives
    • News Releases
    • Staff
    • Store Policies
  • Services Toggle menu
    • Custom Jewelry Design
    • Direct Diamond Importer
    • Gold & Diamond Buying
    • Jewelry Appraisals
    • Jewelry Insurance
    • Jewelry Repairs
    • Jewelry & Watch Care
    • Layaways
Find the Perfect Diamond Engagement Ring at Fernbaugh's Jewelers.
LEARN MORE
SHOP CUSTOM DIAMOND ENGAGEMENT RINGS

New Arrivals

67 products
Sort by
Price, low to high Price, high to low Title, A-Z Title, Z-A Date, old to new Date, new to old Best Selling Featured
1 in stock
Left Right Quick buy
Gold and Diamond Wrap Around Ring
$479.00
3 in stock
Quick buy
10KR Round Diamond Set in Marquis Shape, 1/10tw
$249.00
1 in stock
Left Right Quick buy
Rose Gold Round Huggie Hoop Earrings
$229.00
1 in stock
Left Right Quick buy
White Gold Round Huggie Hoop Earrings
$229.00
1 in stock
Left Right Quick buy
Gold Hexagon Huggie Hoop Earrings
$299.00
1 in stock
Left Right Quick buy
Gold and Diamond Sideways Cross Necklace
$999.00
1 in stock
Left Right Quick buy
White Gold Filigree Cross Necklace
$299.00
1 in stock
Left Right Quick buy
Rose Gold Paperclip Chain
$699.00
1 in stock
Left Right Quick buy
Gold Organic Open Circle Ring
$329.00
1 in stock
Left Right Quick buy
High Polish Gold Band (2mm)
$239.00
1 in stock
Left Right Quick buy
High Polish Gold Band (3.7mm)
$499.00
1 in stock
Left Right Quick buy
Gold "Mrs." Ring
$209.00
Left Right Quick buy
Lab Grown Created Diamond Earrings 1/2, 3/4, 1 Carat Total Weight
From $599.00
diamond heart pendant in 10k rose gold
Quick buy
Diamond Heart Pendant In 10K Rose Gold
$249.00
diamond pendant in 10k rose gold
Quick buy
Diamond Pendant In 10K Rose Gold
$249.00
diamond infinity love heart knot pendant necklace in 14k white gold (2 ctw)
Quick buy
Diamond Infinity Love Heart Knot Pendant Necklace In 14k White Gold (2 Ctw)
$6,249.00
diamond infinity love heart knot pendant necklace in 14k white gold (1 1/2 ctw)
Quick buy
Diamond Infinity Love Heart Knot Pendant Necklace In 14k White Gold (1 1/2 Ctw)
$4,375.00
diamond infinity love heart knot pendant necklace in 14k white gold (3/4 ctw)
Quick buy
Diamond Infinity Love Heart Knot Pendant Necklace In 14k White Gold (3/4 Ctw)
$1,875.00
pear shape starburst halo diamond engagement ring in 14k white gold (1ctw)
Quick buy
Pear Shape Starburst Halo Diamond Engagement Ring In 14k White Gold (1ctw)
$4,999.00
oval starburst halo diamond engagement ring in 14k white gold (1ctw)
Quick buy
Oval Starburst Halo Diamond Engagement Ring In 14k White Gold (1ctw)
$4,999.00
emerald cut starburst halo diamond engagement ring in 14k white gold (1ctw)
Quick buy
Emerald Cut Starburst Halo Diamond Engagement Ring In 14k White Gold (1ctw)
$4,999.00
oval diamond halo ring in 14k white gold (1/2 ct. tw.)
Quick buy
Oval Diamond Halo Ring In 14K White Gold (1/2 Ct. Tw.)
$1,499.00
diamond v-shaped stackable wedding ring in yellow gold (1/4ctw)
Quick buy
Diamond V-Shaped Stackable Wedding Ring In Yellow Gold (1/4ctw)
$435.00
diamond v-shaped stackable wedding ring in sterling silver (1/4ctw)
Quick buy
Diamond V-Shaped Stackable Wedding Ring In Sterling Silver (1/4ctw)
$435.00
1 2 3 · Next »
Free shipping
Label
New styles
Gift cards
5.0 Google rating
Fernbaugh's Jewelers

206 North Michigan St.
Plymouth, IN 46563

Tel: (574) 203-0294

Get Directions>>

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
STORE HOURS

Monday; Closed

Tue-Fri:  10AM - 6PM

Saturday: 10AM - 3PM

Sunday Closed

After hours by appointment

Text 574-936-1577

Quick links
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Custom Jewelry Design
  • Direct Diamond Importer
  • Store Policies
  • Do not sell my personal information
Newsletter

Sign up for exclusive offers, original stories, activism awareness, events and more.

American Express Apple Pay Diners Club Discover Facebook Pay Google Pay Mastercard PayPal Shop Pay Venmo Visa
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Custom Jewelry Design
  • Direct Diamond Importer
  • Store Policies
  • Do not sell my personal information
© 2022 Fernbaugh's Jewelers.

CUSTOM DIAMOND ENGAGEMENT RINGS

Find the Perfect Diamond Engagement Ring at Fernbaugh's Jewelers.

SPEAK WITH A DIAMOND EXPERT TODAY!

LEARN MORE

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest