WHERE NORTHERN INDIANA GETS ENGAGED

With our expert advice, wide array of in-house services and exclusive collections - finding the perfect engagement ring has never been easier.
We look forward to meeting you again and again and again.

Shop Our Exclusive Ring Collections

From Google
From Google
My husband and I love Fernbaugh’s! They helped my husband create my engagement ring, my wedding band, my husbands wedding band, my pearls that I wore for our wedding, and coming soon we will be working with Morgan to create a few more pieces. They value their customers and they always show it. Thank you to the entire staff for always being great!
— Brooke W.
From Google
Brian, Lori, and their staff, have always taken good care of my needs. When I decided to get a diamond solitaire ring, Lori texted me from Antwerp with a photo of the most beautiful oval diamond! And Brian set it just perfectly exactly the way I wanted. I’ve also had a few pieces made with great results. And, it’s always a pleasure to see their dog, Ruby, in the store. Thank you!
— Elaine A.
From Google
I was looking for a new setting for the half carat diamond in my engagement ring and found a beautiful one at Fernbaughs, except it was set with a sapphire. They were able to remove the sapphire and set my stone. I cannot say enough good things about the service, communication, and workmanship Fernbaughs provided throughout the process.
— Kathryn D.
From Google
Fernbaugh’s Diamonds & Fine Jewelry in Plymouth: knocked it out of the Park for my wife & me! I wanted to surprise my Wife of 37 years with a new Wedding ring & Band. I also wanted to have her old chip of a Diamond. Put into a new setting since her’s was broken. When I walked in I was greeted by Samatha & I told her what I was wanting to do and she gathered her team and they went to work! The care and level of knowledge blew me away. I was so appreciative of the care and support through this process. The results are amazing and we could not be more pleased! Thank you Fernbaugh’s & Samantha!
— Art J.
From Google
Fernbaugh’s is a great place to get permanent jewelry. I have two bracelets and a necklace!
— Hillary H.

Discover the Perfect Engagement Rings at Fernbaugh's Jewelers Jewelry Store in Plymouth, Indiana

Welcome to Fernbaugh’s Jewelers, the premier destination for exquisite jewelry in Plymouth, Indiana. Our commitment lies in providing you with a wide variety of engagement rings that will capture your heart and symbolize the love and commitment you share with your spouse. Finding the ideal engagement ring has never been easier with our expert advice and fantastic inventory.

The Process of Choosing the Right Ring

We understand that selecting the perfect engagement ring can feel overwhelming, but we're here to make the process seamless and enjoyable. Our knowledgeable and friendly staff is dedicated to providing you with expert guidance every step of the way. When you visit our store, our experienced team will take the time to understand your preferences, budget, and desired aesthetics. We will educate you on the 4 Cs (cut, clarity, color, and carat) and help you choose the ideal combination that suits your taste and budget. You can trust our expertise to assist you in making an informed decision that will bring you joy for a lifetime.

What Are the Benefits of Buying From Us?

At Fernbaugh's Jewelers, we provide an exceptional jewelry experience with our commitment to expert craftsmanship, unique and personalized designs, an extensive selection, trust and integrity, and a focus on legacy and generational jewelry. Our in-house jewelry designers and goldsmiths are experienced artisans known for their exceptional craftsmanship, ensuring that every piece of jewelry, including our proposal rings and custom designs, is meticulously created to the highest quality and aesthetic appeal standards. With our custom design services, you can create one-of-a-kind jewelry pieces tailored to your preferences and style. At the same time, our wide variety of proposal rings caters to every individual taste and preference, including options like lab-grown diamond proposal rings and exclusive designs from partners such as SallyK. We have built a reputation for trust and integrity, providing exceptional customer service and upholding the highest ethical standards in sourcing diamonds and gemstones. When you choose to shop with us, you can trust in your jewelry's authenticity and exceptional quality, allowing you to make your purchase with confidence and peace of mind. We also understand the significance of jewelry as cherished heirlooms, and our focus on restyling and preserving the value of jewelry allows us to transform outdated pieces into fresh, contemporary designs that can be treasured and passed down through generations.

Visit our jewelry store in Plymouth, Indiana today, and let us help you embark on this beautiful journey of finding the perfect engagement ring. Together, we will create a cherished symbol of your love that will be forever treasured.