fernbaughs jewelers in plymouth

Established in 1933 by Earl and Geraldine Fernbaugh. The small jewelry repair shop grew into a jewelry store with a repair shop in the house. Fernbaugh’s moved to its current 416 East Broadway location in downtown Logansport in 1947.

Since Earl Fernbaugh’s passing, the store was operated by Alvin Scheerer, Florence Sutton, and Oris McGuire. Since 1982, the store has been owned and operated by Oris and Sally McGuire. Their son, Derek, daughter Lori VanDuyne, and son-in-law Brian VanDuyne bought the Logansport location in 2005 and opened a second, stylish Plymouth location at 206 North Michigan Street in February, 2006.

“We feel fortunate to have this fine history guide us into the future,” comments Lori McGuire Van Duyne

Fernbaugh’s Diamonds and Fine Jewelry is a community gem to the proud folks of Logansport, Indiana, and Plymouth, Indiana. The two friendly and stylish stores to shop diamonds, gold, pearls, and more. Our Web site is designed for you to easily find perfect pieces too as well as gather pertinent information.

Whatever your stage in life or whatever your heart desires, whatever your feelings – Fernbaugh’s has the selection to inspire you - sparkling diamonds, colored stones, and detailed gold, perfect bridal sets, unique birthday gifts, anniversary bangles, an add-a-pearl for a precious daughter, a keepsake gift for a graduating young man, the Indiana jewelers of Fernbaugh’s Diamonds and Fine Jewelry can help.

It’s not about us; it’s all about you. Please visit our jewelry stores in Logansport and Plymouth, Indiana. Enjoy our new Shopify website designed to show you more of what is in-store. We look forward to meeting you again and again and again.