Skip to content
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • Pinterest
CALL NOW (574) 936-1577
Search
Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Account Search Cart
  • Engagement Rings
    • SallyK Perfect Love Engagement Rings
    • In-Store Engagement Rings
    • Lab Diamond Engagement Rings
    • Oval Engagement Rings
    • Custom Engagement Rings
    • Choose Your Own Center Stone - Semi-Set Engagement Rings
  • Wedding Bands
    • SallyK Wedding Bands
    • Ladies Wedding Bands
    • Men's Wedding Bands
  • Jewelry
    • New Arrivals
    • Estate Jewelry
    • Diamond Stud Earrings
    • Bracelets
    • Earrings
    • Gift Ideas
    • Necklaces
    • Permanent Jewelry
    • Rings
    • Stackable Rings
    • Ania Haie
    • Gent's Jewelry
    • Red Box
  • Our Store
    • About Us
    • Book In-Store Appointment
    • Book Virtual Consultation
    • Contact Us
    • Blog
    • Giving Back
    • History
    • How to Ask
    • Incentives
    • News Releases
    • Staff
    • Store Policies
  • Services
    • Custom Jewelry Design
    • Direct Diamond Importer
    • Gold & Diamond Buying
    • Jewelry Appraisals
    • Jewelry Insurance
    • Jewelry Repair
    • Jewelry & Watch Care
    • Layaways

GET DIRECTIONS

GET DIRECTIONS

RED BOX SPECIALS

View all
1.56 ct princess cut solitaire engagement ring on model
14kw 1.56ct princess cut diamond solitaire engagement ring on model
Quick buy
The Solana | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$10,499.00
2 CTW Diamond Studs in "Martini" Style 3-Prong Setting_150-01534
2 CTW Diamond Studs in "Martini" Style 3-Prong Setting_150-01534
2 CTW Diamond Studs in "Martini" Style 3-Prong Setting_150-01534
Quick buy
2 CTW Diamond Studs in "Martini" Style 3-Prong Setting
$7,999.00
14K White Gold Oval Center Three Stone Engagement Ring on model
Quick buy
The Sabrina | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$3,999.00
Quick buy
The Keely | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$3,199.00
Quick buy
Flourish by Fernbaugh's | 14K Yellow Gold Lab Grown Oval Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring
$2,999.00
yellow gold bracelet on the wrist
bangle clasp with safety latches
back of bangle bracelet
14% off
Quick buy
14KY Gold and Diamond Cluster Station Bangle Bracelet | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$2,999.00 $3,499.00
Sale
14K Two-Toned Cross Over Ring with Princess Cut Diamonds .38 CTW
14K Two-Toned Cross Over Ring with Princess Cut Diamonds .38 CTW side 1
14K Two-Toned Cross Over Ring with Princess Cut Diamonds .38 CTW side 2
14K Two-Toned Cross Over Ring with Princess Cut Diamonds .38 CTW on model
Quick buy
The Sally | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$2,999.00
14kw oval cut double halo engagement ring on model
closer, more detailed view of 14kw oval double halo engagement ring on model
Quick buy
The Kiara | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$2,999.00
170-00227__2022-10-11-13-17-48.png
14KW Lab Grown Diamond Classic Tennis Bracelet close up
14KW Lab Grown Diamond Classic Tennis Bracelet safety clasp
14KW Lab Grown Diamond Classic Tennis Bracelet on model
30% off
Quick buy
Flourish by Fernbaugh's 14KW Gold Lab Grown Diamond Classic Tennis Bracelet
$2,799.00 $3,999.00
Sale
14ky hinged bangle bracelet
bracelet on the wrist
bangle clasp with two safety latches
back of bangle with high polish finish
10% off
Quick buy
14KY Gold and Diamond Hinged Bangle Bracelet | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$2,699.00 $2,999.00
Sale
Quick buy
SallyK Collection Twisted Shank Engagement Ring
$2,599.00
14kw double halo engagement ring on model
closer view of 14kw double halo engagement ring on model
14K White Gold Round Center Diamond Halo Style Engagement Ring 1CTW on hand
Quick buy
The Hayley | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$2,499.00
Quick buy
SallyK Collection Halo-Style Multi-Faceted Round Diamond Engagement Ring
$2,399.00
SallyK Twisted Shank Halo Engagement Ring Side 1
SallyK Twisted Shank Halo Engagement Ring
SallyK Twisted Shank Halo Engagement Ring Side 2
Quick buy
SallyK Collection Halo-Style Engagement Ring with Twisted Shank
$2,199.00
Quick buy
14KW Baguette and Round Inside/Outside Diamond Huggie Hoop Earrings .82 CTW
$1,999.00
14KW Salt and Pepper Diamond Engagement Ring on model
9% off
Quick buy
The Siobhan | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$1,999.00 $2,199.00
Sale
14kw halo style engagement ring on model
closer, more detailed view of 14kw halo style engagement ring on model
Quick buy
The Jillian | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$1,999.00
10% off
Quick buy
14KW Pear-Shaped Salt & Pepper Diamond Pendant with Black Diamond Accent | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$1,799.00 $1,999.00
Sale
14KY Accented Solitaire Engagement Ring with Round Center Stone on model
15% off
Quick buy
The Maggie | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$1,699.00 $1,999.00
Sale
Round Halo Lab Grown Diamond Engagement Ring
Round Halo Lab Grown Diamond Engagement Ring Side 1
Round Halo Lab Grown Diamond Engagement Ring on Model
15% off
Quick buy
Flourish by Fernbaugh's 14KW Gold Round Halo Lab Grown Diamond Engagement Ring
$1,699.00 $1,999.00
Sale
Free Shipping on Orders over $250
New Styles
Gift Cards
5.0 Google Rating

Jewelry Store in Plymouth

206 North Michigan Street
Plymouth, Indiana 46563

Tuesday-Friday 10 am - 6pm

Saturday 10 am to 3 pm

Directions
Fernbaugh's Jewelers

206 North Michigan Street
Plymouth, Indiana 46563

Telephone: (574) 936-1577

Get Directions>>

  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • Pinterest
Our Hours

Tuesday - Friday 10 am - 6 pm

Saturday 10 am - 3 pm

Text Us! (574) 936-1577

Quick links
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Custom Jewelry Design
  • Direct Diamond Importer
  • Store Policies
  • Do not sell my personal information
  • Terms of Service
  • Refund policy
Newsletter

Sign up for exclusive offers, original stories, events and more.

American Express Apple Pay Diners Club Discover Google Pay Mastercard Visa
© 2025 Fernbaugh's Jewelers. Powered by Shopify
Your cart
Checkout
Your cart is empty
Start shopping

ENGAGEMENT RINGS

From Earth’s Finest to Lab-Crafted Perfection – Diamonds Made for Forever.


Where to Find Us:
206 North Michigan Street
Plymouth, Indiana | 46563

Get Directions>>

SHOP NOW