Skip to content
GET THE PERFECT ENGAGEMENT RING - START DESIGNING TODAY!
GET DIRECTIONS
Search
  • Engagement Rings
  • Wedding Bands
  • Jewelry
  • Our Store
  • Services
Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Account Search Cart
  • Engagement Rings
    • SallyK Perfect Love Engagement Rings In-Store Engagement Rings Lab Diamond Engagement Rings Oval Engagement Rings Custom Engagement Rings Choose Your Own Center Stone - Semi-Set Engagement Rings
    • Gabriel & Co
    • Build Your Custom Ring
  • Wedding Bands
    • SallyK Wedding Bands
    • Ladies Wedding Bands
    • Men's Wedding Bands
  • Jewelry
    • Diamond Stud Earrings
    • Bracelets
    • Earrings
    • Gift Ideas
    • Necklaces
    • Permanent Jewelry
    • Rings
    • Stackable Rings
    • Gent's Jewelry
  • Our Store
    • About Us Book In-Store Appointment Contact Us Blog Giving Back History How to Ask Incentives News Releases Staff Store Policies
    • Under New Management
  • Services
    • Custom Jewelry Design
    • Direct Diamond Importer
    • Gold & Diamond Buying
    • Jewelry Appraisals
    • Jewelry Insurance
    • Jewelry Repair
    • Jewelry & Watch Care
    • Layaways

RED BOX SPECIALS

View all
14ky oval halo style engagement ring on model
closer view of 14ky oval halo style engagement ring on model
14KY Halo-Style Diamond Engagement Ring with Oval Center Stone On Model
Quick buy
The Kinsey | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Regular price $27,999.00
1.56 ct princess cut solitaire engagement ring on model
14kw 1.56ct princess cut diamond solitaire engagement ring on model
Quick buy
The Solana | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Regular price $14,699.00
2 CTW Diamond Studs in "Martini" Style 3-Prong Setting_150-01534
2 CTW Diamond Studs in "Martini" Style 3-Prong Setting_150-01534
2 CTW Diamond Studs in "Martini" Style 3-Prong Setting_150-01534
Quick buy
2 CTW Diamond Studs in "Martini" Style 3-Prong Setting
Regular price $11,199.00
Quick buy
Flourish by Fernbaugh's | 14K Yellow Gold Lab Grown Oval Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring
Regular price $4,899.00
14KY Accented Solitaire Engagement Ring with Round Center Stone on model
Quick buy
The Maggie | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Regular price $4,199.00
14kw halo style engagement ring on model
closer, more detailed view of 14kw halo style engagement ring on model
Quick buy
The Jillian | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Regular price $4,199.00
4KY Halo-Style Diamond Engagement Ring with Emerald Cut Center Stone side 2
14ky halo style engagement ring with emerald cut center on model
closer view of 14ky emerald cut halo style engagement ring on model
4KY Halo-Style Diamond Engagement Ring with Emerald Cut Center Stone on hand
Quick buy
The Mavis | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Regular price $2,799.00
Quick buy
14KW Pear-Shaped Salt & Pepper Diamond Pendant with Black Diamond Accent | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Regular price $2,519.00
14kw Black Diamond engagement ring on model
up close detail view of 14kw black diamond engagement ring on models hand
10% off
Quick buy
The Magdelena | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Sale price $2,239.00 Regular price $2,499.00
Sale
3% off
Quick buy
Flourish by Fernbaugh's Vivid Blue Diamond Pendant | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Sale price $1,259.00 Regular price $1,299.00
Sale
7% off
Quick buy
14K White Gold Diamond Wedding Band 1/3 CTW | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Sale price $1,119.00 Regular price $1,199.00
Sale
6% off
Quick buy
14K White Gold Black Diamond Halo-Style Pendant | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Sale price $839.00 Regular price $895.00
Sale
front view of 14ky gold and diamond teardrop shaped pendant on wheat chain
Quick buy
14KY Gold Teardrop Shaped Pendant with Diamond | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Regular price $839.00
Quick buy
The Lindsey | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Regular price $839.00
front view of 14kw diamond hoop earrings
side view of 14kw diamond hoop earrings
Quick buy
14KW Diamond J Hoop Earrings 1/4 CTW | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Regular price $699.00
13% off
Quick buy
The Kelsey | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Sale price $699.00 Regular price $799.00
Sale
14KW Diamond Circle Pendant .15 CTW
Quick buy
14KW Diamond Circle Pendant .15 CTW | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Regular price $699.00
Quick buy
14K Yellow Gold and Diamond Half Hoop Earrings | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Regular price $419.00
front view of 14ky open heart pendant on an 18 inch solid gold box chain
Quick buy
14KY Open Heart Pendant | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Regular price $419.00
Quick buy
14KW Sapphire and White Topaz Ring | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
Regular price $419.00
Free Shipping on Orders over $250
New Styles
Gift Cards
5.0 Google Rating

Jewelry Store in Plymouth

206 North Michigan Street
Plymouth, Indiana 46563

Tuesday-Friday 10 am - 6 pm

Saturday 10 am to 3 pm

Directions
Fernbaugh's Jewelers

206 North Michigan Street
Plymouth, Indiana 46563

Telephone: (574) 936-1577

Get Directions>>

  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • Pinterest
Our Hours

Tuesday - Friday 10 am - 6pm

Saturday 10 am - 3 pm

Text Us! (574) 936-1577

Quick links
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Custom Jewelry Design
  • Direct Diamond Importer
  • Store Policies
  • Terms of Service
  • Refund policy
Newsletter

Sign up for exclusive offers, original stories, events and more.

American Express Apple Pay Diners Club Discover Google Pay Mastercard Visa
© 2026 Fernbaugh's Jewelers. Powered by Shopify
Your cart
Checkout
Your cart is empty
Start shopping