Skip to content
Facebook
YouTube
Instagram
TikTok
Pinterest
Search
Account
Search
Cart
Engagement Rings
SallyK Engagement Rings
In-Store Engagement Rings
Lab Diamond Engagement Rings
Custom Engagement Rings
Choose Your Own Center Stone - Semi-Set Engagement Rings
Wedding Bands
Ladies Wedding Bands
Men's Wedding Bands
Jewelry
New Arrivals
Estate Jewelry
Diamond Stud Earrings
Bracelets
Earrings
Gift Ideas
Necklaces
Permanent Jewelry
Rings
Stackable Rings
Ania Haie
Gent's Jewelry
Red Box
Our Store
About Us
Book In-Store Appointment
Book Virtual Consultation
Contact Us
Blog
Giving Back
History
How to Ask
Incentives
News Releases
Staff
Store Policies
Services
Custom Jewelry Design
Direct Diamond Importer
Gold & Diamond Buying
Jewelry Appraisals
Jewelry Insurance
Jewelry Repair
Jewelry & Watch Care
Layaways
GET DIRECTIONS
GET DIRECTIONS
Black Friday Jewelry Deals in Plymouth IN
Filter
Sort by
Featured
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Filters
Sort by
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Apply
Quick buy
14KW July Birthstone Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$99.00
Quick buy
14KY June Birthstone Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$99.00
Quick buy
14KW May Birthstone Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$99.00
Quick buy
14KW June Birthstone Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$99.00
Quick buy
14KW February Birthstone Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$99.00
Quick buy
14KW September Birthstone Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$99.00
10% off
Quick buy
14KY December Birthstone Dangle for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$89.00
$99.00
Sale
Quick buy
14KY October Birthstone Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$99.00
10% off
Quick buy
14KY October Birthstone Dangle for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$89.00
$99.00
Sale
Quick buy
14KY January Birthstone Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$99.00
Quick buy
14KW August Birthstone Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$99.00
Quick buy
14KY February Birthstone Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$99.00
Quick buy
14KW December Birthstone Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$99.00
Quick buy
14KW November Birthstone Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$99.00
Quick buy
14KY March Birthstone Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$99.00
Quick buy
14KW January Birthstone Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$99.00
Quick buy
14KY Bezel Set Blue Topaz Dangle for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$115.00
Quick buy
14KY Leaf Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$99.00
Quick buy
14KY Cross Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$59.00
Quick buy
10KY Heart Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$69.00
Quick buy
14KY Dachshund Dangle for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$80.00
Quick buy
14KW Cross Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$69.00
Sold out
Quick buy
14KY Cross Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$69.00
Quick buy
Sterling Silver Leaf Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$19.00
Quick buy
Sterling Silver Four-Sided Engravable Bar Dangle for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$49.00
Quick buy
Sterling Silver Oval Engravable Bar Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$19.00
Quick buy
Sterling Silver Flat Engravable Bar Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$39.00
Quick buy
Sterling Silver Oval Engravable Tag Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$19.00
Quick buy
Sterling Sliver "Mrs." Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$29.00
Quick buy
14KY Martini Glass Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$89.00
Quick buy
14KY Dog Bone Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$59.00
Quick buy
14KY Wine Glass Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$109.00
Quick buy
14KY Heart Charm for Permanent Jewelry with Lab Grown Diamonds | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$129.00
Quick buy
14KY Bow Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$59.00
Quick buy
14KY Butterfly Charm for Permanent Jewelry with White Sapphires | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$89.00
Quick buy
14KY Studded Cross Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$129.00
Quick buy
14KY Puffed Heart Charm for Permanent Jewelry
$79.00
Quick buy
Sterling Silver Celtic Knot Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$19.00
Sold out
Quick buy
Sterling Silver Guiding Star Charm for Permanent Jewelry | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$29.00
Sold out
45% off
Quick buy
Sterling Silver Oval Cut Aquamarine Ring | Fernbaugh's Jewelers
$99.00
$179.00
Sale
« Previous
·
1
…
11
12
13
14
·
Next »
Your cart
Close
Close
Your cart is empty
Start shopping
Close
HOLIDAY GIFT IDEAS
This Christmas, celebrate your love with timeless jewelry or the perfect engagement ring—Earrings.
SEE STORE FOR DETAILS
Where to Find Us:
206 North Michigan Street
Plymouth, Indiana | 46563
Get Directions>>
SHOP NOW